Oil or Water? Comparing Lash Serum Bases Maximum Lash Lift

Eyelash serums have become increasingly popular in recent years as more people seek thicker, longer, and fuller lashes. We apply these serums topically to condition the lashes and stimulate their growth. Using a quality lash serum can lead to a number of benefits, including:

  • Longer, fuller lashes: Lash serums contain ingredients that condition the lashes and follicles to encourage growth. With consistent use, many people see noticeable improvements in lash length and thickness over time.
  • Strengthening lashes: The conditioning properties of lash serums also help strengthen lashes, so they are less prone to breakage and fallout. This leads to thicker-looking lashes.
  • Reduced need for mascara: With fuller, longer lashes, many people find they do not need to wear as much mascara. The results speak for themselves.

With consistent use of an effective eyelash growth serum, most people begin to see results within 4-8 weeks. Maximum results are typically achieved around the 3 month mark.


Oil-Based vs. Water-Based Serums

Oil-based and water-based lash serums each have their own sets of pros and cons to consider:

Pros of Oil-Based Serums

  • Penetrate the hair shaft more deeply to condition lashes from within
  • Provide thicker texture for coating lashes
  • Hydrate and soften lashes
  • Contain fatty acids and vitamins for extra nourishment

Cons of Oil-Based Serums

  • Can feel heavy or greasy, especially in humid climates
  • Prone to running into eyes, requiring careful application
  • Potential to clog glands around lash follicles

Pros of Water-Based Serums

  • Lightweight, non-greasy feel
  • Quickly absorbed without residue
  • Less likely to run into eyes
  • Allow lashes to feel soft without weighing them down

Cons of Water-Based Serums

  • Don't penetrate as deeply into the lash hair
  • Require more frequent application
  • Can dry out more quickly than oil-based options
  • May not condition lashes as thoroughly

The choice between oil-based and water-based products comes down to personal preference in texture and application. Those with oily skin or in humid climates may prefer water-based serums, while people in dry climates or with maximum conditioning needs might opt for oil-based serums.





Key Ingredients in Lash Serums

Lash serums contain a variety of ingredients that help promote lash growth. Some of the most common ingredients include:


  1. Castor Oil - Rich in ricinoleic acid, castor oil helps condition lashes and protect them from breakage. It also contains antioxidants that support hair growth.
  2. Olive Oil - High in vitamins A and E, olive oil moisturizes lashes and conditions them. It also contains fatty acids that improve hair strength.
  3. Coconut Oil - With its high lauric acid content, coconut oil has antimicrobial and anti-inflammatory properties. It helps condition lashes while preventing infections.

    Other Key Ingredients

    1. Peptides - Small protein fragments that help stimulate collagen production and cell turnover. This supports healthier, stronger lash growth.
    2. Biotin - Also known as vitamin B7, biotin plays a key role in keratin production. Keratin is a protein that makes up hair and nails. Biotin supports lash growth and strength.
    3. Vitamin E - A powerful antioxidant that helps protect lashes from free radical damage. It also moisturizes lashes and boosts healthy growth.


      Brush-on Serums

      A small, mascara-like wand applies brush-on serums directly to the lash line. With this targeted application, you can deposit the serum precisely where you need it to condition lashes.

      Benefits of brush-on application:

      • Direct contact with lashes allows maximum absorption of active ingredients
      • Easy to control amount and coverage
      • Applicator wand enables precise application along lash line
      • Compact packaging with brush is portable for on-the-go use

      Potential drawbacks:

      • Brush may transfer oil and dirt back into bottle, contaminating serum
      • Brush fibers may harbor bacteria if not cleaned regularly
      • Not as sanitary as single-use pads
      • Can be messy and result in product waste if not applied carefully
      • Wand applicator less suitable for lower lashes




      Serum-Infused Pads

      Serum-infused pads provide a convenient method of applying lash serums. The pads are pre-soaked with serum, allowing you to simply wipe the formula directly onto lashes.


      Benefits of Serum Pads

      Convenience - Pads are easy to use and eliminate the need to manually apply serum with a brush. Simply wipe the pad across the lashes.
      Mess-free -Serum pads help avoid potential spills and messes that can happen with brush application. The pad contains the serum.
      Even application - The pad allows for smooth, even application across all lashes. It can be easier to fully coat lashes using a pad than a brush.
      Portability - Individual serum pads can be packed for on-the-go use. They take up little space in a purse or bag.
      Hygienic - Each pad is new and sterile. You avoid contaminating a bottle of serum, as can happen with repeated use of a brush.


        Potential Drawbacks

        Drying time: Serum on pads can take longer to dry than brushed-on serums. The pad continues to release serum as it dries.

        • Cost: Pre-soaked pads are often pricier than buying a serum bottle on its own. You pay for the pad's convenience.
        • Irritation: Wiping pads across delicate eyelids and lashes may irritate some users, especially those with sensitive skin.
        • Less control: Compared to using a precision brush, it can be harder to fully control the application.


        Comparing Effectiveness

        When it comes to seeing real results, both oil-based and water-based lash serums can be effective if formulated properly. However, oil-based serums seem to produce more dramatic lengthening and thickening over time.

        Several studies have shown that using lash conditioners with key active ingredients like peptides, biotin, and panthenol can increase lash length and thickness. In one study, using an oil-based lash serum daily for 6 weeks increased average lash length by over 25%. Another 12 week study using a different oil-based serum led to a 46% increase in average lash length and a 70% increase in lash thickness.


        Side Effects and Precautions

        When using lash serums, there are some potential side effects and precautions to be aware of:

        • Eye irritation: Some ingredients, like prostaglandins, may cause irritation, redness, or itchiness. This is more common with eyelash growth serums than conditioners. Always do a patch test first.
        • Iris darkening: Ingredients like bimatoprost and latanoprost may cause increased pigmentation and darkening of the iris. This is irreversible.
        • Fat loss around the eyes: Anti-aging ingredients such as retinoids can cause fat loss under the eyes after prolonged use. This can make the eyes appear sunken.
        • Hypertrichosis: excessive hair growth in other areas, such as the cheeks or eyelids. This is a rare side effect.
        • Allergic reactions: Certain ingredients, such as botanical oils and extracts, may cause allergies in some people. If any reactions arise, discontinue use.
        • Avoid getting serum in the eye itself, as it can cause redness and irritation. Apply only to the upper lash line.


        Some people who should avoid lash serums include:

        • Individuals with sensitive eyes or skin. Instead, opt for a gentle conditioner.
        • Contact lens wearers. The ingredients may interact with contacts.
        • Pregnant or breastfeeding women. Inadequate research on ingredient safety.
        • Those with medical conditions like glaucoma or ocular hypertension. Consult a doctor first.

        Always do a patch test before using a new lash serum. Start with a small amount and monitor for any reactions. Discontinue use if any irritation occurs.


        DIY Lash Serum Recipes

        When making your own DIY lash serum at home, you have the choice between oil-based and water-based formulas. Here are some recipes for each:

        DIY Oil-Based Serum Recipes

        Castor Oil and Coconut Oil Serum

        • 2 tsp castor oil
        • 1 tsp coconut oil
        • 5 drops vitamin E oil

        Simply mix the ingredients together in a small bottle. Castor oil helps thicken lashes while coconut oil conditions.

        Castor Oil and Olive Oil Serum

        • 1 tsp castor oil
        • 1 tsp olive oil
        • 3 drops lavender essential oil (optional)

        Mix the oils and add lavender for a nice scent. The olive oil helps moisturize lashes.

        Rosehip Oil and Jojoba Oil Serum

        • 1/2 tsp rosehip seed oil
        • 1/2 tsp jojoba oil
        • 2 drops vitamin E

        Combine the rosehip and jojoba oils which are both great for promoting lash growth.

        DIY Water-Based Serum Recipes

        Aloe Vera Gel Serum

        • 1 tbsp aloe vera gel
        • 1 tsp castor oil
        • 1/2 tsp honey
        • 2 drops vitamin E oil

        Mix together the aloe vera gel, castor oil, honey and vitamin E. The aloe helps condition lashes while the honey acts as an anti-inflammatory.

        Green Tea Serum

        • 1 green tea bag or 1 tsp loose leaf green tea
        • 1 oz hot water
        • 1 tsp castor oil

        Steep the green tea in hot water for 5 minutes. Remove tea bag or strain leaves. Mix in castor oil once tea has cooled. The antioxidants in green tea can help strengthen lashes.

        Chamomile Tea Serum

        • 1 chamomile tea bag or 1 tsp dried chamomile
        • 1 oz hot water
        • 1/2 tsp coconut oil 

        Steep the chamomile tea bag in hot water for 5-10 minutes. Remove tea bag and mix in coconut oil once cooled. Chamomile helps calm irritation.


        Key takeaways

        Lash serums can be an effective way to enhance the length, thickness, and fullness of eyelashes. When choosing a lash serum, it's important to consider the ingredients as well as the application method.


        When used as directed, lash serums can be a safe option for enhancing lashes. Focus on choosing a serum with proven ingredients at effective concentrations. Combine with proper diet, hydration, and lash care for optimal results. Consistent, patient use is needed, but longer, fuller lashes are an achievable goal.


        LASH SERUM

        Back to blog